Paramore is one of my top five favorite bands of all time. I first started listening to them a bit later than most people I know, during my sophomore year of undergrad when their self-titled album came out. I was instantly hooked. I remember spending that entire summer with Brand New Eyes (one of my top five favorite albums of all time) on repeat. During that time, whenever I played the drum set at home I’d warm up to Fast in My Car because I loved the disco-ish beat the drums did. Even though Paramore doesn’t completely line up with the type of music I personally write and play, they’ve had an outsized influence on my musical style.
Before I get into the album, I have to take a moment to really appreciate Paramore as a band. First, Paramore has been around for almost 20 years at this point — their first album All We Know Is Falling came out in 2004, which is wild. The members of Paramore were fucking kids when they started — Hayley Williams was 16 when their first album came out. They’re essentially veterans at this point and they’re all only in their early 30s. They’ve gone through many lineup changes over the years, but I think their current iteration as a trio is their best one.
My favorite thing about Paramore though is that they’re not afraid to jump between genres. After Laughter (2017) was an insane album because it fucking caught everyone off guard. Up until that point, Paramore had consistently been an alternative rock band. It was their bread and butter. There were always three things that were guaranteed whenever they put out a new album:
There would be heavy bangers on it
Hayley would be singing like her life depended on it
Zac would be beating the shit out of the drums
And then After Laughter came out and it had the last two guarantees but not the first. It was very much an indie pop/rock album! And it fucking ruled. Most bands aren’t brave enough to jump genres like that, and it doesn’t always sound well when they do. Not only did Paramore do it well, but people loved it. After Laughter is considered to be one of their best albums, and I think they gained a lot of new fans in that era too.
I love This Is Why. I think it’s a phenomenal album, to the point where I forced myself to stop constantly listening to it because I didn’t want to get tired of it. About a year ago when I first heard Paramore was working on a new album, I wasn’t sure what to expect. After Laughter was a very different sound for them, and I didn’t know if This Is Why would also be different. In the end, I think This Is Why is a new sound for Paramore, but there are still moments where the old Paramore shines out. Songs like The News and C’est Comme Ca have aspects of the old, alternative Paramore where the energy is up and Hayley is screaming a little. There are a few poppy songs too, like Running Out Of Time and You First that remind me a bit of After Laughter.
One of my favorite things about This Is Why is the rhythm section. In a typical modern band, the drums drive the rhythm section and the bass follows the drums and complement it. I like to think of the drums and the bass as being in a marriage because of how closely tied they are. On This Is Why, there’s a really interesting dynamic where the drums still drive the rhythm section and the bass complements it, but the rhythm guitar takes an outsized role in helping to complement the drums and drive the songs as well. Taylor York is a really rhythmic guitar player and he really shines on this album. You can hear an example of this during the chorus of This Is Why (the song) where the rhythm guitar and drum parts are sync up, to the point where the bass is even taking a backseat. I think this is a recurring theme on this album — the bass parts are really great, and they get straight to the point. There’s not a lot of flair or dancing around the neck that can be typically heard on previous Paramore albums. It’s almost like the drums and rhythm guitar are in a marriage, and the bass is their supportive mutual friend. I think part of this dynamic is due to Taylor and Zac being the only full time members of Paramore who play in the rhythm section. Brian Robert Jones is a fantastic multiinstrumentalist who is Paramore’s touring rhythm guitarist and he played bass on this album, which I thought was lovely.
I’d be remiss if I also didn’t talk about Zac’s drumming on this album. Zac is a phenomenal pocket drummer who’s really good at managing song dynamics. This has probably always been the case, but I don’t think it was easy to tell until After Laughter when Paramore’s sound and dynamics evolved. On all accounts, This Is Why is a very dynamic album. Songs like Thick Skull go from energetic highs to emotional lows, and Zac is really good at supporting all of that. On Thick Skull specifically, I love the energy in the chorus and the triplet hits he does. I find Zac to be very talented in general. In general I think a lot of people believe that in bands, the goal of the drummer is to be loud as shit the entire time and hit stuff really hard. And while that can be true and valid in a lot of bands and scenarios, great drummers (in my opinion) are ones who can manage the dynamic and lead the rest of the band. I think this really shines on this album.
One other random thing I love about This Is Why would be Hayley. She’s insanely talented, her vocals are superb as usual, and the lyrics are emotional. Hayley has always been the main songwriter of Paramore and I feel like the roles she plays became even more obvious on This Is Why, because some of the songs remind me of her solo music of 2020 and 2021. Crave and Thick Skull remind me a bit of the sound of her album Petals For Armor.
My favorite songs on the album are This Is Why, Running Out Of Time, Figure 8, and Thick Skull. I love the bass line in the chorus of Running Out Of Time and how simple yet impactful it is. I love how jazzy the drums sound in This Is Why. I love Hayley’s vocal dynamics on Figure 8. I can feel the emotion when she sings “spinning in an endless figure 8.” I love the weird guitar shit Taylor does all over this album, it sounds like he’s genuinely just having a good time.